Charlie was Day's first kiss. Day hadn't eaten for 2 days and he had stolen food from Charlie's father's restaurant. After finding out, Charlie forced Day to make a deal with her; he would have to kiss her and help her father for 3 days in exchange that she would let him go.

Day admits to June that he doesn't consider his kiss with Chalie as his first kiss, and considers his first kiss to have been when he first kissed June.